SUCCESS! Quick update. I booted my "new to me" ibook g3 in OS 9.2 and then plugged the HD into it via USB. Disk Warrior recognized it but couldn't fix it. Disk Utility recognized it but couldn't fix it. Was it Admiral Nelson who said the boldest move is the best? I re-initialized the disk. Pretty scary when you get to the "all data on the disk will be erased" screen. Did I mention the only copy of all our wedding pictures were on the disk? So the disk is now empty, but it works. I re-boot in OS 10.4, connect the disk and run Data Rescue. It finds everything, I copy all those golden files to a new drive and then back them all up to DVD. Post Script: I took that old drive and put it in a cheap fire wire enclosure, it works great, tested fine. Finally, I would recomend pulling an HD out of an Ibook with a dead logic board, worked for me.