[bencurtis]

I currently have a QuickSilver G4 933Mhz and Harmon Kardon Soundsticks (original usb version).
I'm planning to upgrade my Mac quite soon to either a new iMac or a MacPro.

I want to get a sound system to use now (stereo is fine for now), that I can later use with either the iMac or MacPro that will enable me to get 5.1 audio from DVDs, or DivX files with AC-3, using VLC player. Also to use for playing CDs/MP3s from iTunes (I realise it won't be 5.1 for that). I've read loads of posts about 5.1 audio in the forums, and it seems these are the main choices:

1. Griffin FireWave (or similar), and a 5.1 computer speaker system with individual analogue inputs.

2. An a/v receiver with Optical-IN, and connect to the iMac/MacPro via optical cable.

I don't have a fixed budget but don't want to spend a huge amount of money. I don't play games so don't care about 5.1 audio for that, just for movies. I'm tending towards the av receiver option *if it actually works well*.

Which would you go for?
Can anyone give their experiences of using Optical-OUT to an av receiver?
Any recommendations for AV receivers/Home Theatre packages that would work?

Thanks in advance...

Ben

[Leonard]

If you can afford it, get the Logitech's Z-5500s on sale somewhere (got mine on sale at Best Buy). Easy to setup and hook up to the Mac Pro and I would imagine the iMac and provides 5.1, at least via DVD Player, so I'd imagine it would with VLC. Doesn't require a soundcard. Works great with iTunes.

Otherwise, you're probably looking at getting a receiver with optical audio in and a good set of speakers.

The firewave seems to have mixed reviews from the people on this board, and I couldn't find another souncard for the Mac that's under $150. A good set of 5.1 speakers is probably going to cost you another $150.