[NeoMac]

Regarding digital camcorders, is the progressive scan feature really worth the extra $$$? Would you recommend it?

I have never seen an image comparison. Could someone post a couple of iMovies that would allow me to see the difference between progressive scan and interlaced scan video?

I have a cable modem, so no need to worry about the file size -- eh, within reason.

Yes! Yes! Yes! Progressive or Movie mode is THE prefered format for anything
distributed on a computer. Unlike your ordinary TV, computers (and their screens)
show full images at a rate of 25 (PAL) or 30 (NTSC) fps.

Most cameras (SONY, Panasonic and other consumer brands) do not have true
progressive scan mode as an option. Only Canons mid and high end prosumer
models have this feature. The Sonys TRV-900 emulates it poorly and its almost
impossible to use.

So if your making DVD´s, webmovies or VCDs. you will be better off with a Canon.
If all you want to do is plug your camera into your VCR or TV, then you really don´t need to spend the extra cash.

In addition to being able to simulate a 16mm movie camera (when using progressive mode) you will also be able to get decent sittl images from your camera when using
this option.

One of the most outstanding cameras for the prosumer level is without a doubt the Canon GL1. Unchangable lenses withstanding, it kicks butt and produces broadcast quality imaging with great color and focus (fully adjustable even in AF mode).

Hope this helped you along the way...

Canontonic

[hmurchison2001]

Progressive scan will appeal to you if you plan on taking video of quick moving objects ie the swing of a bat at a baseball game or someone running...basically any sport. However if what you record is fairly basic then it might not be too appealing at the additional price increase.

No, it is actually the other way around. If you record something in motion, you should
use the default video mode (fields). Only then will your camera be able to capture reasonable motion. Progressive scan works best with slow to medium fast motion.

But in any case, opting for a cheaper camera really just tells you how seriously you take the concept of videography. No pain, no gain...:-)

At the end of the day though, its really the photography, editing and postproduction that determines what the viewer will experience.

Remember, your buddies or family are not objective!