[Rooskibar03]

So I've had my iMac for two years now and it hasn't given me any troubles, but I'm getting the itch for a new toy.

What are your thoughts of going from a 17" 2.0 G5 to a Intel Mini with a 20" screen?

My normal usage of the machine consists of a a lot of iPhoto usage, web and email, some iMovie work, not at much as I would like, and lately ripping and converting movies for my Apple TV. I do break out PS and Illustrator from time to time for work use, but that's maybe 20% of my overall usage.

Will I be satisfied with the performance of a Mini, or should I just keep my iMac and be happy?

Also if anyone thinks this is a possible trade opportunity, let me know.

[Veltliner]

I could not imagine to trade an iMac for a mini.

Before I bought my iMac, I was considering the mini, but went for the iMac for several reasons, mostly for graphic performance, which is poor with the mini because of its integrated graphics card (integrated in the motherboard, no separate card).

If you want a new toy, why don't you wait for the next generation of iMacs, that might be just around the corner, together with the next version of OSX, Leopard.

Now that would be a nice toy.

[roller]

I am the yearbook adviser at a local high school. As you see in my sig, I have a lab of 20+ macs I've purchased over the last seven years. We create the yearbook using Photoshop, InDesign as well as a DVD supplement using iMovie. My students use both the mini and older iMacs to do their work. Each has a machine he prefers. That said, in my experience, an newer mini is probably comparable to an older iMac, so I don't think you will see any dropoff.

That said, I have to agree with Veltliner. I think I would be happier with a next generation iMac than a current (or even next gen) mini. However, if cost is the motivating factor, I do not think you would regret the decision to move to a mini, especially if you spend some money on extra RAM.

Back to the iMac: if you have to purchase monitor along with your mini, get the iMac. You will spend roughly the same (if not more) and have less of a machine on which to do your work.

My $.02...

[Rooskibar03]

Thanks for the feedback.

I went over to the local Apple store today and spent some time on a Mini. I can't say it was any faster or slower then what I have now, but playing in the store is somewhat different then using it on a daily basis at home.

I have to say the style of the 20" display is so much nicer, just not as bulky feeling as the iMac.

I guess I'll just ride this out for a little longer and see what comes out in the next few weeks or months. Beside, do I really need to be spending cash on a computer upgrade, when the holy grail of geek toys will hit the streets on the 29th...

[roller]

Originally Posted by Rooskibar03 

Beside, do I really need to be spending cash on a computer upgrade, when the holy grail of geek toys will hit the streets on the 29th...

Amen...