Have you reset the Power Manager (PMU)? If not, try that and then callibrate the battery again. To reset the PMU, shut down the computer and make make sure you're connected to your power adapter.
Press and hold Shift+Control+Option and while holding those, press and hold the power button to a count of 5. Release everything and press your power button to start up the computer. Your date and time will be wrong, so you'll have to reset that unless you're hooked to a network and are set to have the date/time adjust automatically.
Keep the adapter plugged in until you are fully charged to 100%. Then, unplug and run off battery power until it goes all the way down to a forced sleep mode (should be 0%). Charge fully again and then use as normal.
If that doesn't help, then you are probably suffering from the dreaded Battery Update problem (like me!), to which there is no cure yet. That's assuming, of course, that you installed the Battery Update (it showed up in Software Update back in December).
Good luck!