How many cycles do you have on the old battery? If you have a lot of cycles, it might start to drop out quickly.
Check out this information:
How to prolong lithium-based batteries
The charts show several hundred cycles of use before losing , so cycle count could be a factor, or maybe your battery just "went bad" with some sort of change in internal resistance or a bad cell or something like that.
Not to be a worrywart, but if I had a new battery on the way due to a recall and my old battery suddenly had a rapid drop in capacity, I'd be inclined to pull it out until the new one arrived. But that's just my opinion.