I also thought of using Automator. This was my first time using Automator and it appears it only works with predefined actions that apps explicitely export. There were no System Preferences actions available. I didn't see a way to do what I want, but admittedly, I only spent a few minutes with it.
If I have to I guess I'll learn AppleScript but I was hoping to avoid that. I figured I can't be the only person who has wanted to do this.
Thanks for the suggestions.