If you've done an Archive and Install, and your issue persists, then you have a corrupt/damaged preference file. Your problem continues even after installing a new OS because the Archive and Install preserves all your user preferences.
Try creating a new user and logging in as that user. Does the problem persist?
You might be able to track down which preferences are giving you grief and remove or replace them in your original account. Or simply keep using the new account, move all your documents over, and erase the problematic user account.